Tennessee Parents - Reclaiming Public Education for our children
  • HOME
  • OUR VOICES/BLOG
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • CONTACT US

Nashville's "Third Way" Plan = Wrong Way

11/19/2014

 
On Tuesday, September 9, 2014, Metro Nashville Public Schools Director Jesse Register stunned the community when he proposed turning East Nashville (a group of historic neighborhoods with a strong tradition of pubic education) into an "all choice" zone dominated by charter schools.  If approved by the Nashville School Board, Register's radical plan could end up being Tennessee's most extreme example of dismantling public education and moving toward an all-charter, New Orleans-style school system (which has been a disaster for students and communities in New Orleans, but a profitable business venture for unaccountable charter operators and private contractors. Click HERE, HERE, and HERE for proof).

What was most confusing about Register's announcement on September 9 was his branding it the "Third Way," harking back to former Governor Phil Bredesen's 2003 inaugural address calling for an end to partisan state politics.  Co-opting Bredesen's language from 11 years ago seems like a head-scratcher, particularly for a plan that has pitted entire neighborhoods against each other in East Nashville.  As it turns out, Register apparently has one of Bredesen's former staff members advising him.

Through an open-records request, East Nashville United (a group of parents and community leaders opposing Register's plan to destabilize public education in their neighborhoods) unearthed a series of emails about the so-called "Third Way" plan. One email in particular jumped out.

On August 28, some 11 days before the bombshell announcement, Register received an email from Nashville School Board member, Jill Speering, expressing concern about the apparent lack of turnaround strategy for the city's low-performing schools. About an hour later, Register forwarded Speering's email to Drew Kim, an education policy consultant, with the comment: "See below! Smile." An hour later, Kim responded by saying, "Great. The 9th will be your time!," obviously referring to the upcoming announcement on September 9.

So who is Drew Kim and why does this email exchange matter? 
Kim is the founder of P3 Consulting, one the many shadowy consulting firms that popped up after Tennessee's 2010 Race to the Top win of millions of dollars. Kim (no relation to Nashville School Board member Kim) also happens to be the former policy advisor for Bredesen. Hence, the Third Way connection.

Kim's client's list, proudly displayed on the home page of his firm's web site (www.p3tennessee.com), reads like a "who's who" of organizations that want to dismantle public education:
  • The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation,
  • Teach for America (Kim is an alumnus),
  • the Hyde Family Foundation (the Memphis arm of the charter school movement, and the lead proponent for the first charter laws in TN)
  • and SAS (the company that maintains the TVAAS data in Tennessee's controversial teacher evaluation system using William "Bill" Sanders' secret mathematical formula for agriculture growth).
Drew Kim was a registered lobbyist for Aspire (a chain of charter schools that operates in California and Memphis).  He was also a lobbyist for Tribal Education (the same UK company that MNPS contracted with for an assessment of their system). Should Drew Kim add Metro Nashville Schools' logo to the list of clients on his website??? 

So let's get this straight...
Jesse Register, who for most of his career was a defender of public education, apparently, has caved under political pressure.  He is now scheming with, and taking advice from, a former Bredesen aide and for-profit consultant who's loading him up with bad ideas on behalf of his anti-public education clients.

This, in a nutshell, is what's wrong with the radical reform movement and weak leaders like Register.  If the Nashville School Board votes to dismantle East Nashville's public schools based on Register's and Kim's radical plan, then school board members across Tennessee should be on the lookout for "all choice" proposals to destabilize their schools, too.

Third Way?  No way.

Illegal Charter School Lobbying - will the IRS investigate?

6/23/2014

 
Charter schools seem to have a bottomless bucket of money, while public schools are scrimping by on beans & rice.  Intense lobbying (funded by out-of-state interests) for the charter school industry has resulted in some pretty sweet laws created in Tennessee that are now making charter operators and investors rich, rich, rich and are destroying our public schools.

A smart group of TN citizens did a little research and are now requesting that the IRS investigate this illegal lobbying for charter schools:
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Click HERE to download the letter

TN Parents has blogged on this issue before (click here)  TN Parents are tired of their voices being trumped by people who write checks.

Note to rich people:  If you want to start a "grassroots" movement, don't put it in your 3-year business plan and pay people big salaries to do it for you.  That is not grassroots, that is fluffy, expensive astroturf.
 

Lobbyists, lobbyists, lobbyists...

3/4/2014

 

UPDATED TN lobbyist info... 
Momma Bears updated their "Silencing our Voices" post again

Picture
Since Momma Bears first posted the "Silencing our Voices" post on Friday, we have learned even more about HB 2293 that would effectively allow County Commissions to remove the ability of elected county school boards to hire lobbyists. 

1) This bill, as written, does not apply to charter schools; therefore, county commissions will not have the authority to control lobbying expenditures by charter schools. This seems extremely unfair because charter schools use public money just like zoned schools. This is just another example of how charter schools are treated differently than traditional, zoned schools in our state. 

2) There are actually 59 registered lobbyists (not 31 as we originally reported) that are pushing privatization and/or testing agendas that, in our opinion, are undermining public schools in Tennessee.  

Here is an UPDATED list of all of these groups and the number of lobbyists they employ:
1. Tennessee Federation of Children (charters, vouchers): 5 lobbyists
2. Tennessee Charter Center: 8 lobbyists
3. Stand for Children (charters, vouchers): 2 lobbyists
4. Beacon Center of TN (vouchers): 2 lobbyists
5. Pearson, Inc. (high-stakes testing): 1 lobbyist
6. K-12, Inc. (for-profit virtual charter schools): 5 lobbyists
7. Aspire Charter Schools: 1 lobbyist (They've had as many as 3.) 
8. National Heritage Academies (for-profit charter company): 3 lobbyists
9. Charter Schools USA (for-profit charter company): 3 lobbyists
10. Education 2020 (K-12, Inc. competitor): 2 lobbyists
11. Connections Education (for-profit virtual charter school): 1 lobbyist
12. SCORE (charters): 2 lobbyists 
13. Nashville Area Chamber of Commerce (They support this bill and lobby for charters.): 5 lobbyists
14. Rennaissance Learning (testing): 4 lobbyists
15. Parent Power Fund (parent-trigger bill): 1 lobbyists 
16. Public Consulting Group: 1 lobbyist 
17. Americans for Prosperity (They support vouchers, charters, and HB 2293): 2 lobbyists
18. Catholic Public Policy Commission of TN (vouchers): 3 lobbyists 

     And last, but definitely not least, 

19. StudentsFirst (charters, vouchers, and Michelle Rhee!): 8 lobbyists

Final Score:
PRO-PUBLIC EDUCATION = 6 lobbyists
PRIVATIZATION/TESTING = 59 lobbyists


3) We have heard from some Tennesseans in a particular county that they asked the current sponsor, Rep. Jeremy Durham, to introduce the bill because they are upset with a particular lobbyist their school district is using to lobby for them. We agree on many issues with them, so we hope to not offend them, but we also hope that they understand that this bill, which is a reaction to something that is happening at a local level has serious repercussions for the rest of our state. And the fact that a group such as StudentsFirst supports this bill should set off alarm bells because this organization has made no effort to hide their belief that elected school boards should be bypassed and handed over to other elected officials, including mayors and governors. 

How this bill could be devastating for other districts across Tennessee:

This bill could really hurt the newly formed municipal public school districts in Shelby County and Memphis.  Over the past 2 years, the Shelby County Commission sued the municipal districts.  There is no doubt that the animosity that the Commission has towards these districts will result in them cutting lobbying out of their budgets. (Please note that the bill is not clear in how it relates to municipal districts and commissions, but based on the overriding theme of the bill, it appears that the Shelby County Commission would likely have the authority to veto municipal-district lobbying monies.) 

In Metro Nashville the Mayor is very much in favor of charters and vouchers and there is little doubt that he will attempt to pressure the City Council to cut lobbying out of the school board budget as well. (It should be noted that the lobbyists that represent Metro Nashville Public Schools lobby against vouchers, for-profit charters, and the state charter authorizer.) 

Some claim that, in the state of Tennessee, county commissions currently have line item veto power over every other county department except for school districts and this would just allow commissions to exercise that same authority over them. But, and this is a very big BUT, the departments over which they exert this authority are appointed by the commissions--they are not elected by voters. School boards, which oversee the development of budgets, are elected by their constituents for the sole purpose of overseeing the function of their schools. County commissions were not elected for this purpose and, thereby, should not have the authority to override the will of the voters who selected, by virtue of their votes, the members of  a  school board.
Picture
Some Knox County residents and teachers have been very unhappy with the actions of their school board and school superintendent. But instead of pushing for legislation that could override the will of every elected school board in the state, they are clearly expressing their disapproval for the school board's actions and will this year elect school board candidates who will support their agenda. It seems that this approach would be effective for the county in question because it will help resolve their concerns and it will continue to give elected school boards the right to determine if they need to pay for lobbyists. And it will protect the county if, in the future, a pro-privatization commission is elected and denies money for lobbying, which will leave the county district with little defense against a variety of destructive bills such as for-profit charters, a state-level charter authorizer, and vouchers that will interject Common Core into private schools. And, believe us, the costs of these lobbyists is far cheaper than the costs taxpayers will incur if the lobbyists for "privatizers" have free reign at Legislative Plaza! 

Picture
Picture
With all due respect for some of the supporters of this bill, this seems to be the equivalent of using a sledgehammer to kill a fly when a simple fly swatter would do. We respectfully urge you to attempt to work out your concerns with your locally elected school board rather than pushing this bill onto the entire state. This will have very serious repercussions for many counties and, ironically, could very well end up backfiring and creating problems for those in the very county who support it. 

We urge those of you reading this to contact Rep. Jeremy Durham and ask him to pull HB 2293. If you are in Williamson County and/or are one of his constituents, it is vitally important that you contact him and let him know that you feel it is a very dangerous bill that sets a terrible precedent. His phone number is 615-741-1864 and his email is rep.jeremy.durham@capitol.tn.gov. You can also contact the members of the Local Government Committee that is meeting on Tuesday and ask them to vote against the bill:
Picture
Rep.matthew.hill@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.richard.floyd@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.dale.carr@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.vince.dean@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.jeremy.durham@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.jimmy.eldridge@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.jeremy.faison@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.steve.hall@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.andy.holt@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.sherry.jones@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.larry.miller@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.bo.mitchell@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.antonio.parkinson@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.mike.sparks@capitol.tn.gov
Rep.mike.stewart@capitol.tn.gov


Good grief... with all those lobbyists, legislators must be worn out!  As one parent said, "it must be like a swarm of mosquitoes at the Capitol, all hungry for our children's education dollars." 

It is no wonder our legislators think our public schools are failing and that the only way to fix it is with the magic charter school or voucher recipes they've been sold by well-paid, professional lobbyists with PR staff who are masters at manipulating data and creating glossy pamphlets.

Legislators, our schools are NOT what you've been told.  Believe US, the parents.  We're in these public schools daily.  We talk to teachers.  Trust us, we know.  We are public school parents from across the Tennessee.  (note from this TNParent author: My kids proudly attend Title 1 schools)
  • Yes, our children are bombarded with too many tests.
  • Yes, our children's hard-working teachers are beaten down from the testing mandates and unfair evaluation systems.
  • Yes, Common Core is making it all much, much worse.
  • Yes, our schools need more funding because they've been doing miracles with the meager dollars they've had to work with.

But, NO... we do not need charter schools, not vouchers, not Common Core, not more standardized tests or testing products, and certainly not more oversight or micromanaging by the TN DOE.  Let teachers teach.  

Please, listen to parents.  We are telling the truth.  We are not paid one penny for writing these emails.  Honestly, we have no clue what we are doing, no lobbying experience among any of us, but it seems that our voices ARE being heard by some of you.  We greatly appreciate your responses and questions.  We will continue to share our voices because our children are worth it.

   

Rutherford County fights back!

3/3/2014

 
The Rutherford County Board of Education is not dumb.  They know that the Governor and his appointed leaders are stealing control from local school districts and giving them to entrepreneurs to profit from.  They also know that lobbyists funded by out-of-state interests are hounding legislators to pass laws to dismantle our public schools and benefit their wallets.   

Tennessee Parents give a standing ovation to Rutherford County Board of Education for this excellent Resolution:
Should other local school districts wish to use this Resolution or use it to write one of your own, click HERE to download Rutherford County's Resolution.

Silencing our voices

2/28/2014

 
A post from a very smart Momma Bear:
Picture
A bill has been introduced in the TN legislature that would allow city councils/commissions to remove funds for lobbying from school district budgets. (HB 2293/SB 2525). This would set a dangerous precedent because it would allow a municipal-level, elected body to dictate how another municipal-level, elected body uses its money. If some councils/commissions decide to exercise this veto authority, they would effectively silence our voices in the halls of the legislature because these lobbyists represent our elected school boards who, in turn, represent us--the voters.  And once our voices have been silenced, the lobbyists from wealthy groups intent on destroying public education will have free reign in the halls of Legislative Plaza.

If you are wondering why a school district/board might need lobbyists, look no further than what is happening with StudentsFirst (SF), a group founded by Michelle Rhee who also happens to be the ex-wife of Tennessee’s Education Commissioner, Kevin Huffman. The Sacramento.-based organization backs charter schools and vouchers and is funded by donations from extremely wealthy individuals, corporations, and foundations—including the Gates and Waltons. SF currently has an office in Nashville, along with 8 lobbyists. 

There are other similar lobbying groups in TN, (who don't have you or your children's best interests at heart) including the following: 

  • Tennessee Federation for Children: Supports charter schools and vouchers. 5 lobbyists. 
  • TN Charter Center: Supports proliferation of charter schools. Employs 8 lobbyists. 
  • Stand for Children: Supports charter schools and vouchers. Employs 2 lobbyists. 
  • Beacon Center of TN: Supports vouchers. Employs 2 lobbyists. 
  • Pearson, Inc.: Publishes Common Core materials and tests. Employs 1 lobbyist.
  • K12 Inc.: Runs K12 for-profit virtual charter school.  Employs 5 lobbyists. 

(Go to this link https://apps.tn.gov/ilobbysearch-app/search.htm to find documentation of these lobbyists.) 

Why do local school boards need lobbyists?
School board members in TN are part-time positions and these representatives do not have the time to follow all of the bills that are going through the legislature. They need the help of lobbyists to help them keep track of bills that directly affect their schools and constituents. And just in case you are keeping score, here are the lobbyists school boards/districts use in our state:

  • Coalition of Large School Systems: Represents Shelby, Nashville, Hamilton, and Knox County school systems. Employs 2 lobbyists
  • Tennessee School Board Association: Represents all school boards who pay dues to it. Employs 1 lobbyist.
  • Tennessee Organization of School Superintendents: Represents interests of school board directors who pay dues to it. Employs 3 lobbyists. 

Final score: 
StudentsFirst & Company = 31 lobbyists!!!
School boards/districts = 6 at the most. 


As you might suspect, StudentsFirst, Stand for Children, TN Charter Center, and other groups reportedly support these bills. They apparently have no problem suppressing the voices of our elected officials and, subsequently, our voices in the legislative process—especially when the views expressed by these officials run counter to their agendas.  

IMPORTANT TO NOTE:  This law does not apply to Charter Schools.  They can hire as many lobbyists as they want to support them.  

(Note: All Momma Bears are volunteers.  We are concerned parents who do this solely because we care deeply about public education.) 
Legislators, please vote AGAINST 
HB 2293/SB 2525
Let our locally elected school board members do their jobs.  
We'll hold them accountable.

    Authors:
    real parents & real teachers
    from TN

    They are afraid to speak up and risk their jobs... They want to protect their children... This blog is for them:  Their voices need to be heard.

    These blogs are emailed to these TN officials:  
    the TN Board of Education, 
    the TN Commissioner of Education,
    the 99 TN House Representatives,

    the 33 TN Senators,
    the Governor of TN,
    every Superintendent in TN,
    hundreds of locally elected school board members across TN,
    and parents... lots and lots of parents.

    Categories

    All
    ALEC
    Arne Duncan
    ASD
    Barbic
    Campaign Contributions
    Charter
    Common Core
    Consultants
    CRA
    Crisis
    EOCs
    ESL
    Evaluations
    Faux Parents
    Governor
    Haslam
    Huffman
    Kindergarten
    KIPP
    Laws
    Legislators
    Lobbyist
    Mcqueen
    NAEP
    Next Gen Science Standards
    Opt Out
    PARCC
    Parents
    Petition
    Plan
    Pre-K
    Protest
    Pta
    Ravitch
    Reform
    RELAY
    Resolution
    Rocketship
    RSD
    SAT10
    School Board
    School Board
    Score
    Sneaky Politician
    Student Data
    Student Privacy
    Students
    Studentsfirst
    Superintendent
    TCAP
    Teachers
    Tenure
    Testing
    Tfa
    TNDOE
    TNReady
    Tree
    Tripod
    TVAAS
    University Of Memphis
    US DOE
    Vouchers

    Archives

    March 2017
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.