Tennessee Parents - Reclaiming Public Education for our children
  • HOME
  • OUR VOICES/BLOG
  • SUBSCRIBE
  • CONTACT US

Bah Humbug! No holiday program this year due to reforms

11/30/2013

 
Our music teacher is has a new evaluation process which includes a lengthy portfolio process. Since she only sees our students once every rotation, there is not time for her to have them practice holiday songs. Also, it is frowned upon for us to miss "teaching time" for anything at all. Award programs were cut this year, too.

This isn't right... even jails have fairly elaborate Christmas programs for the inmates! We are becoming more of an institution than actual institutions. We are taking all of the fun out of learning, out of life. Everything we do has to be tied to a "tested objective." I am really becoming ashamed to be a part of teaching. We used to have freedom to make learning fun, now we don't. We are strictly limited to what we can and cannot do.

Since there are so many components that have to be completed by a certain deadline, our music teacher can't stop to practice holiday songs. Basically, it sounds like what has happened with classroom teachers. If we can't tie the activity to an actual tested objective, we can't do it.
 
For example, this week my students are participating in short plays for reading. There is a wealth of research showing that practicing the scripts over and over through repetition helps build reading fluency and comprehension. However, to fully put on one of these short plays, technically called "readers' theaters," I have to give the students a small amount of time to decorate their scenes, work on simple props etc. Since drawing the background for the play is not assessing a tested objective, we aren't supposed to do it at school. It doesn't fit into our evaluation model. However, I cheated today and gave my students about 30 minutes to create their props for their performances tomorrow. Everything we do, and now our music and art teachers do, must be tied to an assessed skill. Since there isn't a music portion on TCAP, yet, our teacher has to turn in portfolios showing the different skills she is teaching the students. Apparently it is extremely rigorous, and she can't miss a single day of teaching what the state deems important to stop and actually sing in class.  
 
We have CC standards that guide our instruction. Supposedly the PARCC test will test these standards. We have always had some sort of standards to guide our instruction. The actual standards are not the main problem. It's all the strings that come with them. I wouldn't focus only on them. It's some of the ways the skills are taught and questionable materials used to teach them. Right now we have tight schedules that squelch teachable moments and creativity.

At this point, they have developed portfolio evaluations along with the regular ones for art and Music teachers. PE teachers are next. I just wish they would leave us all alone to teach.
 
(This was posted anonymously, with permission, to protect the employment of these teachers in TN.  This teacher does not have the freedom to reveal her school district without the possibility of retribution.)

Is this really fair???  

11/30/2013

 
I teach high school English II in Davidson County.  I would love to teach literature that is exciting and meaningful to students.  My whole school's AYP depends upon me and 4-5 other English teachers, plus Algebra teachers. There are approximately 100 teachers at my school, but AYP depends upon a handful of us. Yes, every teacher is supposed to teach reading and writing, but it really comes down to English teachers, specifically English II.  We pre-test, test, re-teach, post-test all of the time.

(This was posted anonymously to protect the job of this English teacher in Davidson County)

Tennessee parents realize the burden that high-stakes testing puts on our children and their teachers.  Testing is robbing MONEY and TIME from our children's education.  

Pendulum

11/25/2013

 
I'm a veteran teacher. I've watched the pendulum swing. It has never swung this far before. We are just data like our kids. Not the loving people who teach children to seek knowledge. Many highly sought after professionals are leaving. So who will teach our children and have the qualifications and understanding of childhood development? I'm scared for my own children.

(This was posted anonymously to protect this Tennessee teacher).

Is the State manipulating data to give our public schools to charter operators?  

11/24/2013

 
Westwood Elementary is a strong neighborhood school.  It has a proud history, has strong support from local church congregations, and is a hub in its community.  In 2012, Memphis residents voted to give up their Memphis City School charter to merge with the successful Shelby County School district.  Westwood parents were eager to be a part of this new merged system. But only 4 months into the newly merged district, Westwood Elementary parents and staff are being told they have no choice:  Their public neighborhood elementary school will be given to an out-of-state charter chain next year against their wishes and despite their protests.

Parents and leaders in the Westwood community know their school's test scores were improving.  Their students were making great gains.  They saw how hard their teachers and students were working.  

They've been researching the other ASD schools that have already been taken over by the state.  They notice that the ASD test scores are dismally low, especially in reading.  They see the crazy new grading scale that the ASD implemented to inflate children's grades.  They question the data and find glaring discrepancies.  

They see these huge red flags:
  • An observant Westwood Dad notices that the ASD is fudging the numbers for some strange reason. The rollup TVAAS Composite averages for the ASD are crazy inflated!  Looking at the 6 ASD schools individual scores  6 schools currently in the ASD on the TN Report Card for 2013 (Cornerstone Prep - Lester Campus, Frayser Achievement Elementary, Corning Achievement Elementary, Brick Church College Prep (Nashville), Humes Preparatory Academy, And Westside Achievement Academy), it is plain to see that those individual school's numbers don't add up to the ASD District's glowing Composite score.  Why???
Picture
Picture
  • This next big question they found on the ASD Superintendent search document printed on the Tennessee Department of Education's Race to the Top waiver.  If you look at the bottom of page 2, you'll find a section that states:  "Schools that are eligible for the ASD have either reached the “Restructuring 2” phase (the fifth year of improvement status) pursuant to the State's accountability system, or they are Title I schools that meet the U.S. Department of Education’s definition of “persistently lowest achieving schools.” Based on current AYP calculations, there are currently 13 schools that are eligible to be part of the ASD. Ten of the schools are categorized as the persistently lowest-achieving schools in the state and the other three schools are in Restructuring 2 and beyond under No Child Left Behind designations. The schools are located in five Tennessee districts, including: Madison County (Jackson), Hamilton County (Chattanooga), Knox County (Knoxville), Memphis, and Metro Nashville."  From February 2012 to September 2013 is 16 months; how does 16 months turn into 5 years of restructuring that makes Westwood Elementary eligible for ASD???
Picture
  • Comparing the "High Priority" schools by year and number, and the years that Westwood Elementary was included as a High Priority School...  Once removed from the High Priority Schools list in July 2008, they did not reappear until the first ASD Priority List was published in February 2012.  Which is odd, because they were not a part of the list in October 2011.  How can a school that was not a High Priority in October 2011 become a High Priority in February 2012, if no high stakes testing is performed within that period??? 


Their neighborhood may be low-income, but they know they are being forced to do something that isn't right for their children and community.  Their public neighborhood school is being handed, on a silver platter, to an out-of-state charter chain.  This is not their choice.  Their choice would be smaller class sizes for their children.  Their choice would be support in their school building from counselors, a full-time school nurse, and assistants.  Their choice would be fixing the leaking windows from the 1950s.  

Their citizens voted to be represented through an ELECTED school board, not a charter chain looking to make money from their children.  The Westwood community isn't fooled.

 
(This was posted anonymously, with permission, to protect the privacy of these parents in Memphis, TN)

Is the ASD targeting the "top of the bottom" schools to try and "cream" the best for their score portfolio???

A rock-solid teacher speaks out against Tripod:

11/22/2013

 
A teacher speaks out against Tripod: I hope that my letter informs every public education school parent in the state of Tennessee about the abuse educators are facing from day to day.  

I received my TRIPOD scores from the 2012-13 school year on Sunday evening, November 3rd, 2013--- one day before my 2013-14 students were to take the TRIPOD.  As I began to look at my scores, I chuckled. I called my husband in the room and he immediately said, "What's this?" "My 2012-13 TRIPOD scores," I told him. "What a joke," he said.  

And he was right. My scores were incredibly low. You see, I am an ESL teacher in Metro Nashville Public Schools. My students are early childhood age, and have little to no developed vocabulary. As I sat at my home computer, looking at the scores I was incredibly horrified, but more so, insulted. One of my lowest areas was a 22/60--- how I CHALLENGE my students. The state average was 50. This didn't make sense. I was a "4" teacher in 2012-13. These scores did not correlate.  

As I went on a tangent, trying to figure out why my scores were so low not just in this one area, but all the way across; I remembered a question my students answering a question on TRIPOD. The question was, "Does your teacher push you to do your best?" I chuckled, remembering my ESL students asking after the survey if it meant that I physically pushed them. Perhaps my students all answered no to this; I would NEVER put my hands on a child.  

This year, the TRIPOD survey is 5% of my TEAM evaluation, and quite frankly--- I don't think it is fair. I did not go to school for over 20 years to be evaluated by 6 and 7 year old children. I did not pay nearly $50,000 of my hard earned money (much of it which I am still paying on) to have a CHILD much less a CHILD WHO DOES NOT SPEAK ENGLISH evaluate my effectiveness as a teacher.

It is my hope and prayer that the state of Tennessee will WAKE UP and realize they are running off the best and the brightest teachers by treating them like dirt. I will be totally honest here--- I have been in this profession less than 5 years and I am not sure how much longer I care to be in it. I am already exploring other career options. Oh, yeah... and remember I am a "4" teacher--- above and beyond what Tennessee likes to call "rock solid."  

Commissioner Huffman and other Tennessee lawmakers must know that to keep the best and the brightest teachers in Tennessee, it is not about paying them more--- it's about treating them with dignity and respect. They have degrees. They went to school. They know what they are doing. Wake up, and remember that. Let's keep our GOOD teachers, not run them out. 

(This was posted anonymously, with permission, to protect the privacy of this teacher in Metro Nashville School District)

Smart Parent:

11/21/2013

 
I pulled my daughter out of school this year. The first 6 weeks of school were horrible. Do not give me the speech that things are harder and they will get used to it. My daughter is 5th grade. She had great teachers. I know because my boys had the same teachers. My boys are in high school. My middle son has excelled because he had such creative teachers.My oldest son is dyslexic and it was the same school and teachers who helped recognize it and deal with it. They helped him to improve but more importantly to regain confidence! They were pushed and worked hard. Their test scores soared and they enjoyed learning. If my oldest had been subjected to common core he would have failed. How do I know? I know because these teachers are not allowed to be creative and step out of so called guidelines. He would never have gotten the help he needed. These kids fall by common core standards. Its almost like that is the plan. 

I have been voicing my concerns for  a while now. I even called the TN Board of Education. It took about 5 calls to even get someone to answer questions. I then caught the lady in an inadvertent omission. I asked, "Why does the Literature book look more like a history book? This does not entice my daughter to read." The lady replied that it wasn’t factual history in the Literature books. I later asked her why they were not reviewing history, and why my daughter wasn't even allowed to bring it home. They were only doing maps, even a local Dollywood map. She said don’t worry they will get history elsewhere. I asked her "where?" to which she replied "their literature books."  When I called her on it, she suddenly had a meeting to go to.

I am angered that our schools are being hurt. Our hands are bound. I will not stop until government is not in control of our schools and people like Bill Gates are not allowed to call our CHILDREN a "marketing management group!"

(This was posted anonymously, with permission, to protect the privacy of this child and her former teachers in Sevier County)


Common Core Field Testing = Free Child Labor

11/19/2013

 
In June of this year,  it was announced that 10% of TN public school students will be involved in field testing of the Common Core test (PARCC) during the 2013-2014 school year. This field testing helps the for-profit creator of the test–Pearson–fine tune the test for the planned administration to all TN public school students during the 2014-2015 school year. Sadly, it also essentially turns our students and teachers into unpaid research and development subjects for a company that is worth approximately 1.5 BILLION dollars.
 
Upset parents in New York state recently created an “invoice” to highlight the costs of the Pearson Common Core field tests to the districts and students. (You can see it at this link.)  Many parents refused the field testing for their children and some openly expressed their anger at Pearson and the NY Department of Education: “If Pearson wants to use my daughter to ‘field test’ during the school day,” opined Brooklyn parent Johanna Henry, “they will have to pay us...  I will use the money to provide my child an enjoyable and relevant learning experience.’”
 
Our students will not only be denied payment for taking the PARCC field test, they will be denied valuable instruction time–time that is arguably more necessary than “helping” a testing company that could easily afford to pay children to take (and teachers to administer) this test outside of school hours.  Instructional time is extremely precious, especially considering that teachers across the state estimate that 30-45 days of instruction are lost each school year due to test preparation and administration. This works out to 2-3 years of lost instruction between kindergarten and 12th grade. The PARCC field test will also create additional stress for our children, especially since the PARCC is supposed to be very different from tests our children have taken in the past.  And finally, this pilot testing will increase the already ridiculous workload for our teachers and could result in pushing even more highly qualified educators out of the profession.  

In addition to the educational and emotional costs of this test, TN will lose out on an untold amount of tax revenue because Pearson does not pay teachers and students to administer/take these pilot tests.
 
The Tennessee Department of Education has not published a list of the schools that will undergo field testing in Tennessee.  Attempts to find out this information have been unsuccessful.  
 
(This was reposted with permission from www.stoptntesting.com, a website, blog, and facebook group with a strong and rapidly growing social media presence in TN)

A teacher tells what is really happening: 

11/16/2013

 
I talked last night to a friend who teaches kindergarten. I would not have thought that she would feel stress. I was surprised when she talked about the pushing of 1st grade curriculum into kindergarten, of her small students who would cry from frustration feeling under pressure, her "babies" she called them. She is 58, had originally planned to teach on to age 65 ... But after discussions with her husband, they are rearranging their finances so that she can exit in two more years, at age 60 instead. Her husband recently told her that perhaps they need to move that date up.

Today, I learned that three of the best teachers we have at our school are planning their exit strategies before they had originally planned.

A 22 year veteran teacher in a hard to fill position is about to finish her EDS. Her plan involves moving out of Nashville into a county system and into admin.

Another phenomenal teacher is retired military. This is his second year teaching. He is amazing and the students often respond to him because of his background. He is a strong, confident man who is a great role model for our students.....but he has decided that the insanity of our system is not for him. He doesn't HAVE to work ... He had expected to make a 2nd career of teaching but the past two years have disillusioned him.

Another 20+ yr, after much thinking and planning, and exploring of options...has found another job.

I am more and more concerned with teachers in mid career who looking for a way out.

I did meet with my financial advisor over fall break. I am going to try to go through spring 2015...but I know now that I can afford to leave spring 2014 if I need to.

All three of the colleagues I talked to today surprised me. I wonder how many others are looking at their options...

(This was posted anonymously, with permission, to protect this veteran teacher in Nashville)

Many excellent, irreplaceable teachers are quitting across TN.  The media across the State has even reported about it...  Click HERE, HERE, and HERE to read more.  

CRA Makes Kids CRY 

11/16/2013

 
The Constructed Response Assessment (CRA) is a state-mandated test made up of math word problems given to grades 3-12 in “preparation” for Common Core testing that will begin in 2015. The first (of three) CRA administrations for this school year occurred in October. (http://stoptntesting.com/2013/11/05/the-cra-test/)

Little-Known CRA Facts:
  • Most students had not yet been taught the material covered on the recent CRA because the standards they were tested on had not yet been addressed in the Common Core Pacing Guide.  Teachers must follow the standards timeline set forth in the Common Core Pacing Guides that are provided by the TN Department of Education (DOE).
  • Because the TN DOE distributes the Common Core standards Pacing Guides, it seems logical that they should have known that students would most likely not have a clue how to answer the questions.
  • Because most students did not know the material tested, many of them suffered undue anxiety and stress as a result of taking this test. For example, one parent said that her 3rd grade daughter came home crying after taking it.  Another parent said that her middle-school son had an anxiety-induced asthma attack and ended up in the ER in reaction to the test. A fourth-grader who tested "advanced" on all sections of the TCAP last school year also suffered anxiety attacks after taking the CRA a few weeks ago  (http://stoptntesting.com/2013/11/05/the-cra-test/). And a 4th grade Metro Nashville teacher recently said the following about the CRA: "I just finished grading CRA and one student's final remarks on the test are: "I tried my best but I think I failed." Breaks my heart! The thing is that this isn't the best student in the world, but he really did try and he didn't leave anything blank. This kid doesn't have the best self-esteem and this just validates his opinion of himself instead of building his self-worth. In my opinion, this is not how to best encourage learning for 9-year olds. He will eventually learn the skills that were tested on the CRA, but he needs to have enough success going forward to build back up his self esteem."
***Parents & teachers call the CRA tests the "CRY" tests!***
This should not be happening to our children.  This is wrong.
  • At least one teacher at each school in TN attended training to learn how to score the CRAs (How much money + time did that cost taxpayers?). The trained teachers then taught the other teachers at their schools how to score these tests. And then our children’s teachers were forced to grade these CRAs. On their own time. Without pay.
 
It is clear that the CRA test is an incredible waste of time and money, but, worst of all, it is cruel to our teachers and students. Which leaves us pondering these questions:
  • Why does the DOE demand such things from our teachers?
  • Why does the DOE purposely set our children up for failure?
  • Why does the state legislature allow this to continue?


Please stand up for our children and put an end to this abusive test.Tennessee parents & children are counting on you!  Thank you. 

This TN student gets it...

11/11/2013

 
Picture
Ethan Young is a high school senior in Knox County.  Ethan courageously spoke at the Knox County Board of Education meeting on November 6, 2013.  Since his video was posted on Youtube just 4 days ago, it has gone viral with over 89,000 views.  His 5 minute speech has gained attention across the nation.

What does Ethan say?  Watch it for yourself.  His understanding, knowledge, and poise will amaze you.  He is the future of TN.  Here is the link:  
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PprP5TCZBRI

Here are some highlights:
  • He knows more about common core than most grown-ups do.  He is absolutely correct when he says that Congress, the Department of Education, State, or Local Governments never voted on the Common Core standards.  He realizes the $4.35 billion of our tax dollars were used as a bribe to coerce states into participating, and that TN received $500 million. 
  • Ethan is smart enough to know that these new standards won't fix our academic deficit.  He knows that there is not even any research even showing common core might work.  Furthermore, he says it shows a mistrust of teachers since they were not consulted in the process.
  • Ethan's respect for his teachers is obvious.  As a student, he has been in the classrooms when his teachers have been evaluated.  He sees firsthand how teachers are impacted.  He says it is like "watching your teacher jump through flaming hoops to earn a score."  Students see what administrators, parents, and legislators don't see:  the stress and anxiety teachers are experiencing. Students notice.  So, listen closely to what he is saying.
  • "Standards-based education is ruining the way we teach and learn."  He asks WHY we are doing it this way?  Ethan knows the answer, saying it is "Bureaucratic Convenience.  It works with nuclear reactors. It works with business models.  Why can't it work with students?"  However, Ethan is smart enough to realize that "Education is unlike every other bureaucratic institute in our government. The task of teaching is never quantifiable."
  • "If everything I learn in high school is a measurable objective, I haven't learned anything."  Wow.  This kid is way more than a test score!!!
  • He gets it: "Creativity, appreciation, inquisitiveness - these are impossible to scale, but they're the purpose of education."  
  • Yes, yes, yes:  "We teach to free minds.  We teach to inspire.  We teach to equip.  The careers will come naturally... Haven't we gone too far with data?"
Listen to this wise student.  Please.
 
<<Previous

    Authors:
    real parents & real teachers
    from TN

    They are afraid to speak up and risk their jobs... They want to protect their children... This blog is for them:  Their voices need to be heard.

    These blogs are emailed to these TN officials:  
    the TN Board of Education, 
    the TN Commissioner of Education,
    the 99 TN House Representatives,

    the 33 TN Senators,
    the Governor of TN,
    every Superintendent in TN,
    hundreds of locally elected school board members across TN,
    and parents... lots and lots of parents.

    Categories

    All
    ALEC
    Arne Duncan
    ASD
    Barbic
    Campaign Contributions
    Charter
    Common Core
    Consultants
    CRA
    Crisis
    EOCs
    ESL
    Evaluations
    Faux Parents
    Governor
    Haslam
    Huffman
    Kindergarten
    KIPP
    Laws
    Legislators
    Lobbyist
    Mcqueen
    NAEP
    Next Gen Science Standards
    Opt Out
    PARCC
    Parents
    Petition
    Plan
    Pre-K
    Protest
    Pta
    Ravitch
    Reform
    RELAY
    Resolution
    Rocketship
    RSD
    SAT10
    School Board
    School Board
    Score
    Sneaky Politician
    Student Data
    Student Privacy
    Students
    Studentsfirst
    Superintendent
    TCAP
    Teachers
    Tenure
    Testing
    Tfa
    TNDOE
    TNReady
    Tree
    Tripod
    TVAAS
    University Of Memphis
    US DOE
    Vouchers

    Archives

    March 2017
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.